[M_Six]

Originally Posted by Jdem2

Love the 15yr Dalwhinnie! Just discovered it recently (about 6 months ago) and was so pleasantly surprised.

Smoky/peaty or no?

[atxgt3]

Picked up some Talisker Storm and Johnnie Walker Green today. Trying both back to back, so far I'm really liking both. Trying to add more single malts and blends to my collection, as if I needed more.

[UncleWede]

Niece drooped off my Christmas present today, Gentleman Jack with a couple glasses. It was lost until she moved this past weekend
I've had a bottle before and couldn't swallow it. Today was a totally different experience Cheers

[larryn]

Originally Posted by M_Six

Smoky/peaty or no?

Not like Aberlour or Laphroaig, but it has some. Great sipper though, and there is smoke, but again, not close to an Islay. Reminds me of vanilla and caramel, smooth, but not too smooth.

[Jdem2]

Originally Posted by larryn

Not like Aberlour or Laphroaig, but it has some. Great sipper though, and there is smoke, but again, not close to an Islay. Reminds me of vanilla and caramel, smooth, but not too smooth.

What I like about it is the smoke is subtle. And honey, don't forget the honey. ;-)

[Axius]

Crown Royal G-Apple or Maple as of late.

[Joekerr]

Originally Posted by Jdem2

Love the 15yr Dalwhinnie! Just discovered it recently (about 6 months ago) and was so pleasantly surprised.

Originally Posted by M_Six

Smoky/peaty or no?

Have had other dalwhinnie's before, but not the 15yr old, but very doubtful that it would be peaty / smoky. It's known as the "Gentle Giant". And the ones I've had have been decent, not my favourite scotch, but decent to be sure. On the milder side.

[Joekerr]

Originally Posted by Axius

Crown Royal G-Apple or Maple as of late.

I'm sorry.

Signed - A Snob.

[Jdem2]

Originally Posted by Joekerr

Have had other dalwhinnie's before, but not the 15yr old, but very doubtful that it would be peaty / smoky. It's known as the "Gentle Giant". And the ones I've had have been decent, not my favourite scotch, but decent to be sure. On the milder side.

Gentle Spirit.

And yes, it is mild and also reasonably priced for a quality 15 year old. That said, the smoke is there.

[atxgt3]

Originally Posted by Axius

Crown Royal G-Apple or Maple as of late.

I think the Jim Beam versions are way better than the Crown. Have you tried them? The apple is great. At first I thought the honey was too sweet, but I got used to it and now I love it when the mood strikes.

I'll drink anything. Signed - Not a Snob.

[M_Six]

Back to Aberlour 12 and a splash of seltzer.

[larryn]

Originally Posted by Jdem2

What I like about it is the smoke is subtle. And honey, don't forget the honey. ;-)

If you like honey as a mixer, find a bottle of Barenjager, a German honey liqueur that enhances whiskey cocktails like nobody's business.

It will be difficult to find though... Worth it.

For good Irish whiskey or Scotch I only have glass and booze, no ice, no mixes, no adders.

[M_Six]

Originally Posted by larryn

For good Irish whiskey or Scotch I only have glass and booze, no ice, no mixes, no adders.

I was that way until I started trying a splash of seltzer (just carbonated water). Now I'm hooked. I still don't do ice in Scotch, but I do keep the seltzer in the fridge.

[ASAP]

Gentlemen pls...

[TXSTYLE]

For tonight's nightcap, this turned out to be an outstanding combo!

[Axius]

Originally Posted by Joekerr

I'm sorry.

Signed - A Snob.

Don't use the S word around me, I don't understand it.

Signed - A drunk with unsophisticated taste buds but attempting to grow

Originally Posted by atxgt3

I think the Jim Beam versions are way better than the Crown. Have you tried them? The apple is great. At first I thought the honey was too sweet, but I got used to it and now I love it when the mood strikes.

I'll drink anything. Signed - Not a Snob.

I have not, I usually would just drink regular Crown until someone told me they had apple and really liked it. I have a bottle of JW Black label, but I know once I open it I will not savor it and end up hammering the whole thing down, so there's that.

[atxgt3]

Originally Posted by Axius

I have not, I usually would just drink regular Crown until someone told me they had apple and really liked it. I have a bottle of JW Black label, but I know once I open it I will not savor it and end up hammering the whole thing down, so there's that.

My girlfriend picked up a bottle of Jim Beam Apple for me and I was hooked. I also got hooked on JW Black, and you're right -- you will end up hammering the whole thing down. At least that's what I do, it's just so good. My GF last week bought me a bottle of JW Blue, I'll definitely have to take it more easy with that.

[Jdem2]

Originally Posted by larryn

If you like honey as a mixer, find a bottle of Barenjager, a German honey liqueur that enhances whiskey cocktails like nobody's business.

It will be difficult to find though... Worth it.

For good Irish whiskey or Scotch I only have glass and booze, no ice, no mixes, no adders.

No, I just meant that there are hints of honey in the Dalwhinnie. Not sure when the last time was that I actually intentionally tasted honey.

That said, I go to Munich on 6/4 for two weeks (no not for an ED ) and I would be happy to look for the Barenjager for you if you want.

PM me and let me know.

[Axius]

Originally Posted by atxgt3

My girlfriend picked up a bottle of Jim Beam Apple for me and I was hooked. I also got hooked on JW Black, and you're right -- you will end up hammering the whole thing down. At least that's what I do, it's just so good. My GF last week bought me a bottle of JW Blue, I'll definitely have to take it more easy with that.

Had a supplier take me out to dinner one day and tried a bunch of different drinks, and holy shit Glenlevit (sp?)...., never again, that shit is raw. Makers Mark..., so so, would probably drink it only at the end of a night of drinking.

JW Blue is delicious. Send it to me, I'll savor it for you.

[atxgt3]

Originally Posted by Axius

Had a supplier take me out to dinner one day and tried a bunch of different drinks, and holy shit Glenlevit (sp?)...., never again, that shit is raw. Makers Mark..., so so, would probably drink it only at the end of a night of drinking.

JW Blue is delicious. Send it to me, I'll savor it for you.

I have some Glenlivet 12 and if that's the one you had, I'm surprised. It's actually a very "mild" scotch as far as scotches go. Did you drink it neat? Try diluting it with a little bit of water. That's what I do with most single malts. Also swish it around your mouth a little bit before swallowing. If you take a big gulp of undiluted scotch and swallow it you will most likely not enjoy the experience.

I can't drink regular whiskey without mixing it with anything, it has to be at least an old fashioned (yummy) or something like that. The additional aging mellows out the scotches a lot and make them a lot more drinkable to me.

[UncleWede]

Originally Posted by Jdem2

Not sure when the last time was that I actually intentionally tasted honey.

Do NOT try that Jack Tennessee honey crap shit thing in a bottle. You probably won't like it.


allegedly (still wipes tongue and it's been weeks since allegedly drank that shit)

[imserious]

Originally Posted by atxgt3

I have some Glenlivet 12 and if that's the one you had, I'm surprised. It's actually a very "mild" scotch as far as scotches go. Did you drink it neat? Try diluting it with a little bit of water. That's what I do with most single malts. Also swish it around your mouth a little bit before swallowing. If you take a big gulp of undiluted scotch and swallow it you will most likely not enjoy the experience.

I can't drink regular whiskey without mixing it with anything, it has to be at least an old fashioned (yummy) or something like that. The additional aging mellows out the scotches a lot and make them a lot more drinkable to me.

Good advice. Glenlivet 12 is mild for a scotch and a great daily. It may just be that you prefer bourbon or American whiskey to scotch.