07-28-2019, 04:48 AM | #23 | |
M6GCComp, Porsche Cayman S PDK, Peug 208 GT1 BPS
518
Rep 1,280
Posts |
Quote:
If for you must use all your four limbs to have this sense of involvement, then that is for you. That is your own peculiarity. Please stop talking about cortical mapping. Cortical mapping is innate and learnt. Your brain would not miss what it never learnt and innate. By the way you are talking to a professional in this area Sometimes the cry for manual gear stick is elevated to a level of religious fervour when all opposing reasoning is not considered but insults are thrown about
__________________
Acceleration is heavenly
|
|
07-28-2019, 08:30 AM | #24 |
Second Lieutenant
95
Rep 232
Posts
Drives: '18 M2 LCI
Join Date: Jun 2018
Location: New Jersey, United States
|
Thanks for everyone chiming in to give advice. I wasn't really looking to start another manual vs automatic debate, but I guess that was inevitable with the questions in my OP lol
__________________
'18 M2 LCI 6spd
|
Appreciate
0
|
07-28-2019, 10:18 AM | #25 | |
Major General
5054
Rep 6,347
Posts |
Quote:
Your definition of involvement is personally yours and you oddly link it to outcomes. However, this discussion has not been about results, similar or not, but rather about the process. It is undeniable that the two experiences are different between a true manual transmission and any form of automatic, for each to decide as better or worse. If you are suggesting that fMRI would be identical for a controlled sample of experienced drivers, such as those motivated enough to slog through reading forum posts, for both manual and automatic transmission usage, then we have two professionals who will agree to disagree pending such research. Perhaps a novice driver taking their first-ever drive on an interstate highway (in an automatic transmission car), sweaty hands gripping the wheel, might experience "total involvement", if not incipient panic, but that is not the basis for a BMW enthusiast forum discussion. There is no such religious fervor here as you suggest, just reasoned rebuttal that "total involvement" for the more enthusiastic sub-segment of the driving population can occur when increased automation replaces activity with "resting". That doesn't mean the automatic isn't excellent, as the one in my 3GT is, nor that it isn't very enjoyable to drive. It simply means engagement is less than total. Is there a logical rebuttal to this based on process and not results?
__________________
2015 228i 6MT/Track Handling/Tech/Cold/Premium/Lighting/Driver Assistance/KCDesign Strut Brace/M2 LCAs/Rogue SSK/BBS SR/PS4S/ER Chargepipe/AA Intercooler/Dinan Shockware/MPerformance Spoiler/Black Grilles/Xpel Ultimate PPF & Prime XR+ Tint/Adam's Ceramic/no CDV
2024 X3 sDrive30i/MSport/Premium/Dynamic Handling/Shadowline/Parking/Xpel Prime XR Plus/Weathertech Cargo Liner |
|
07-28-2019, 11:17 AM | #26 | |
M6GCComp, Porsche Cayman S PDK, Peug 208 GT1 BPS
518
Rep 1,280
Posts |
Quote:
The difference is the process, the results are the same. I prefer to use the paddles than the gear stick even though I used the gear stick all my life until my F10. However I hardly drive in full automatic as I always shift the automatic gear stick to manual and in Sport plus. I hope you know in this position, the car would not automatically shift the gear up for you. You know one thing you can do with semi automatic but not able to do with gear stick is racing from the red light in straight line, putting the gear in full automatic and be satisfied that you extract all the speed from the car even when you lose. Otherwise one would be thinking: Had my car be automatic It would have been faster........
__________________
Acceleration is heavenly
Last edited by babaikram; 07-28-2019 at 11:25 AM.. |
|
Appreciate
1
MassNerd172.50 |
07-28-2019, 11:45 AM | #27 |
Lucky13
219
Rep 1,765
Posts |
I have an X1 E84 MSport with paddle shifters and M235 with manual, I used the paddle shifters twice in 7 years and said what a waste of my fingers and never used them again.
__________________
1995 325i, 1996 328ci, 1997 528i, 1997 Z3 2.8, 2000 528i, 2001 X5 3.0, 2001 330i Convertible, 2002 M3 Convertible, 2003 M3 Coupe, 2004 M3 Coupe, 2004 Z4 3.0, 2004 X3 3.0, 2007 X3 3.0, 2007 335i Convertible, 2013 X1 28 sdrive, 2014 M235 manual, 2020 X3 30i Xdrive
|
Appreciate
0
|
07-28-2019, 12:02 PM | #28 |
Private First Class
42
Rep 109
Posts |
This debate never ends and it never gets "solved" buy what YOU want and enjoy it. Everyone has their personal preference. People love to justify their decisions... there has been some very excellent advice in this thread, I would consider all the info and then decide.
How do you plan to use the car? Which would you prefer? Finally, test drive and see for yourself. |
Appreciate
1
734jeant13.50 |
07-28-2019, 05:06 PM | #29 |
Post Advisor
1832
Rep 1,777
Posts |
Exactly. You've actually just proven every stick shift driver's point. The variance in process is what is exciting. As one of the leading experts on neuroplasticity in the US, I can assure you that fMRIs will be different for a person who truly enjoys the process of rowing their own gears vs. that same person in an automatic, including DCTs and flappy paddles.
It's like a master piano player on a grand piano vs an iPad. Different process, same "results" or outcome. Or a real relationship resulting in a baby (I won't get into the process of that here) vs artificial insemination. Different process, same result. BTW, fMRIs are quite different in both settings. |
Appreciate
1
Sportstick5053.50 |
07-28-2019, 05:09 PM | #30 |
Post Advisor
1832
Rep 1,777
Posts |
Bottom line, get what makes your fMRI light up!
|
Appreciate
1
Sportstick5053.50 |
07-28-2019, 06:37 PM | #31 | |
Major General
5054
Rep 6,347
Posts |
Quote:
I am typing this (and everything recently) with my one non-dominant hand, while my other arm recovers in a post-op sling (rotater cuff). I have been experiencing the increased cerebral activity controlling my non-dominant side hand as I learned to write, type more quickly, use clothing buttons, etc. Giving up the manual transmission would have an opposite effect of subduing the areas that activate the left leg and stimulate it to dance through a smoothly executed double-clutch downshift. With neurological evidence suggesting that even periodically moving your watch to the non-dominant arm is beneficial, I plan to continue with more, not less, activity.
__________________
2015 228i 6MT/Track Handling/Tech/Cold/Premium/Lighting/Driver Assistance/KCDesign Strut Brace/M2 LCAs/Rogue SSK/BBS SR/PS4S/ER Chargepipe/AA Intercooler/Dinan Shockware/MPerformance Spoiler/Black Grilles/Xpel Ultimate PPF & Prime XR+ Tint/Adam's Ceramic/no CDV
2024 X3 sDrive30i/MSport/Premium/Dynamic Handling/Shadowline/Parking/Xpel Prime XR Plus/Weathertech Cargo Liner |
|
Appreciate
0
|
07-29-2019, 04:19 AM | #32 |
msej449
518
Rep 721
Posts
Drives: M235i Convertible +LSD 2016
Join Date: Nov 2013
Location: South Coast UK & Swiss Alps
|
I'd say not to conflate two separate questions, (a) manual or auto and (b) RWD vs AWD, but treat them as separate sets of pros/cons.
Re the manual vs auto, I've gone through this journey over the last 40 years and appreciate the interest in at least owning one manual car, especially given the trend towards autonomous vehicles. But if you can, I'd make it something where the manual capability can shine. In my case this was a separate 'fun' car (a Lotus Elise), in the case of other forum members, it's often a similar road-legal but track/handling-oriented car that wouldn't normally be a daily drive. Obviously, a separate 'fun' car is fine if you can afford it, but many can't, so it's a compromise, like so many things in life. Even so, after about 4 years with the Elise, and a couple of (very) close shaves on public roads, I also realised that I need to go on track to take things any further, and sold the Elise and used the savings on running costs to fund track sessions instead. I'd say that the ZF8 auto box Crossed The Line for me i.e. the line where, in a car that I was using as a DD, the effectiveness and convenience of an auto that also had a manual mode and paddles, outweighed the occasional superiority/fun of a full manual. This isn't to say that the ZF8 + Sports Auto can't do 'fun' - just that it doesn't take you as far into manual space as - obviously - a manual will. The RWD vs AWD discussion is so well covered that I'd just point you to the considerable volume of posts on the topic, and leave you to decide for yourself. So perhaps you might take a look at any local track courses that let you drive a variety of manual cars on a proper track, with instruction. I'm lucky, as I live near the Goodwood Circuit here in the UK, and so there are a variety of courses on offer. Of all those I've done, ironically, the one I most enjoyed (and which I've posted about on other threads) was the Wet Weather course: where they use the Euro BMW 140i with ZF8 Sports Auto as the instruction car. I still can't get over doing a reverse J-turn in an auto at 40mph. And it was only £99 for an hour's on-track instruction in their car.
__________________
2016 M235i Convertible Estoril Blue & Oyster
2023 Peugeot e-208 GT (electric) Last edited by msej449; 07-29-2019 at 04:38 AM.. |
Appreciate
1
CP911996.00 |
07-29-2019, 06:33 AM | #33 |
Private
32
Rep 71
Posts |
We are cut from different cloths. I learned to drive stick on an e93 M3 on a ~15 hour drive from NC to the northeast. I did stall a couple times, once at Starbucks pit stop because someone beeped at me . If OP watches some YouTube videos and takes it easy I’m sure he could handle a modern BMW manual tranny especially with the built in rev matching on downshifts. Not saying it’s the best way to learn but not unprecedented especially if you’re an enthusiast and have a general gist of things to begin with
|
Appreciate
0
|
07-29-2019, 10:27 AM | #34 |
Captain
379
Rep 707
Posts
Drives: 2016 M235i Convertible
Join Date: Jul 2016
Location: The Ville
|
Y'all are missing the big picture - both are great. I love my 6MT because I love driving my M235i vert. With a 6MT in it, I know I when I go out to the garage it will always be there waiting for me because my wife hates driving a MT car, even though she is quite accomplished at it. If it had an AT, she'd pick it every time and I'd be stuck taking her Q5.
__________________
16 BMW M235i Alpine White Convertible / MT (Daily Driver)
16 Audi Q5 3.0T (Wife's Daily Driver) 66 Porsche 912 (Project) 24 GMC Sierra 1500 SLT Standard Bed, 3.0 TurboDiesel, Max Tow |
Appreciate
0
|
07-29-2019, 12:04 PM | #35 |
Lieutenant
230
Rep 555
Posts |
It really comes down to whether you are a driving enthusiast, or performance enthusiast. If you want THE FASTER car, get the auto, if you want the one where you will enjoy the drive a bit more, get the manual.
Unless you commute in LA... auto probably for you. Like I said, I own a manual, and auto, they are both fun in their own right, everyone chiming in how one is better than the other, is just justifying their own bias, better at what? They are each better at different things. So there is no single blanket statement, he knows what he would prefer honestly, our job is to give him advice on both and he can better judge which use case he would prefer more.
__________________
|
Appreciate
1
Jashue216.00 |
07-29-2019, 12:29 PM | #36 |
Private First Class
37
Rep 129
Posts |
6MT rwd on the m240i is just a lovely experience. It brings a smile to my face every time I get in. Came from an F30 3-series ZF 8AT, great car, loved it, but my 2er is just so much more engaging. Added to the fact that manuals will likely only be reserved for the next M2/M3/M4 there's few opportunities left. I drive my 2er during the winter in Toronto. Definitely can be a touch squirrelly if you throttle too hard (my winter's are x-ice3's) but still very safe and manageable for the car enthusiast. I wonder how much better winter traction would be with an LSD...
|
Appreciate
2
CP911996.00 Edslittleworld41.00 |
08-02-2019, 11:54 PM | #37 |
New Member
2
Rep 10
Posts |
Interesting topic as I went through this exact decision a year ago.
1. I was going to buy used. I'm done with new cars. 2. With RWD, I wanted LSD with the manual. The LSD was a must for all of the reasons cited here. 3. No interest in auto. Never drove it. Fast forward a few months. I couldn't find a car with LSD and it would cost 2k to have one installed. I decided to include xdrive cars in my search just because. I ended up finding an xdrive car with MPE and other accessories installed for the price I wanted to pay. I drove manuals exclusively for 30 years (my other car is a manual). The ZF8 is the first auto that didn't piss me off. No, it isn't perfect. I only use the paddles during spirited driving because the computer holds the gears too long IMO. It's not the same as the manual, period. That said, I don't miss the manual at all, and the 2 manual 240s that I drove had very solid transmission IMO. Very enjoyable. I would consider owning one, but I'm not iching to get rid of the 235 xdrive. NO regrets with the purchase. I enjoy having traction. I'm no longer interested in having a tail happy driving experience. Been there, done that. For me, the xdrive auto worked well as a replacement for a 6MT with LSD. I will replace the manual car in 3 years and may consider a newer 2 series if I can find one with a LSD. We'll see. Bottom line. The choice depends on the driving experience that you want. These 2 cars drive differently regardless of transmission due to weight and AWD/RWD. For me, I made the right choice. |
Appreciate
0
|
08-03-2019, 05:19 AM | #38 |
First Lieutenant
164
Rep 395
Posts |
You need to choose between practicality and fun.
I GUARANTEE to you that RWD+Manual will be more fun. I spent many months more looking for my M235i to get it in manual. Now, the question is: can you take the hit in less practicality? Like, if you live in NJ area, you probably need to swap to winter tires late fall, and a bit earlier in the fall if you choose RWD. Also, same thing for manual x auto. If you plan to DD it, ask yourself: How long do you stay in a bumper to bumper situation? I'd say if you drive more than 30 minutes each way bumper to bumper, it will be more annoying to drive in manual. Some people have more tolerance than others, but I think under 30 minutes is pretty endurable. I disagree what the 2er 6MT is a bad transmission. It works great for me. |
Appreciate
0
|
08-03-2019, 05:23 AM | #39 | |
First Lieutenant
164
Rep 395
Posts |
Quote:
|
|
Appreciate
0
|
08-03-2019, 11:08 PM | #40 |
New Member
5
Rep 8
Posts |
The question you want from the car...are you looking for a tool or a lover. The auto is definitely the best tool for getting you from point A to B. The manual is like a lover, where you need to coax her to get the best out of her...hearing every rev to know when to shift, feeling when to downshift to open her up etc. She can also be a whining bitch and will test you as you slog through traffic.
My 0.02. My lover is the manual rwd M240i. My tool is an i3 coder with Traffic Jam Assist. I guess I’m a lucky guy getting the best of both worlds. |
Appreciate
0
|
08-04-2019, 12:00 PM | #41 |
Major
598
Rep 1,237
Posts
Drives: 2015 M235ix
Join Date: May 2015
Location: United States
|
Ah, California! A frugal wife and a hot one on the side.
|
Appreciate
0
|
08-04-2019, 12:24 PM | #42 |
Major
433
Rep 1,115
Posts |
These cars aren't world beaters even when tuned, so you might as well go for the best driving experience. I've had a RWD 6 speed since 2014, and it's been through 5 winters now and I've never been stuck or had trouble. The combination of winter tires and traction control are more than you need. You can always add limited slip differential as well, I did last summer and it definitely helps. The manual in these cars is incredible easy to drive and rewarding.
|
Appreciate
0
|
08-05-2019, 06:00 AM | #43 | |
E4 Mafia
350
Rep 432
Posts |
Quote:
I check in with 6MT RWD vote. MT is all about you and what you can do and feel. to me, there is no better feeling than a perfect rev-matched downshift. I don't drive it for efficiency or to gain a few tenths in acceleration. most won't notice those 10th's or even a good enough driver to make em count. I have snows for all my rwd cars. no problem driving the old rwd E46 in 9" of snow. having multiple sets of tires, storing and swapping isn't convenient for most, but if you can swing it, it's worth it. good luck finding and enjoying your new sled, no matter which you decide!
__________________
Squad - '90 E30 325i MT (226k) | '98 E36/5 318ti MT (160k) | '03 E46 325i MT (156k) | '04 E46 330xi MT (195k) | '15 F22 M235i MT (66k) | '15 F30 335i MT (85k)
KIA - '91 E30 325i AT (146k) | '02 E46 325i MT (212k) Bring back the purple M stripe |
|
Appreciate
0
|
08-05-2019, 06:42 AM | #44 |
Major
598
Rep 1,237
Posts
Drives: 2015 M235ix
Join Date: May 2015
Location: United States
|
F1 cars and most other serious purpose-built race cars have SMG 'semi'-automatic transmissions with paddle shifters, very similar to your ZF automatic in feel, with 8 speeds, just like the ZF. Is someone going to claim that these cars do not provide entertainment and engagement?
I have nothing against manual transmissions, having learned to drive at the age of 10 on a McCormick Farmall tractor with a three-speed manual, but . . . As I have noted several times previously, if you want true engagement with the road, get a good bicycle. |
Appreciate
0
|
Post Reply |
Bookmarks |
|
|