[m3driver999]

Hello All,

Currently drive a 335d/6AT and also a 235i/6MT.
The 2's come in different flavors, from base to mild, then the M2.
Having driven briefly the M2, 330i(B48/8AT), 240i/8AT; 120d.

The 8AT has evolved into a worthy opponent of the 6MT and 7DCT.
Engine wise the B48/B58 are quite nice, and improved over prior N26,N55 offered.

It all depends on the flavor your are aiming for, and amount of DIY you are willing or want to do or pay to do, or just aiming for turn-key hassle free ownership. Ideally many would go for the M2, but depends on budget/needs, some other options may be more suitable (ie less flashy, more civil for daily use, MPG, etc)

IMO, an ideal daily 2 series could be:
230i B48 is plenty good
(big fan of torque, too; so the 228i 6MT would be TBD)

M-sport appearance package

8-speed auto w/ paddles
(though I am 6M/T fan)
(AT has a higher numerical axle)
(and lower gearing of AT version means better acceleration)

Track handling package *optional*
THP gets the 235i brakes, adap suspension, steering rack,
If not opting for the THP, then the M2 has a BMW M Performance 2-Way Adjustable Coilover Kit, which in theory may fit a 2 series..that should take care of below expectations handling (front spindle strut attachment may be showstopper)

OK, seems my comments are performance biased, for creature comforts, the HK audio is nice, the BMW APPS,

For reference, likes and dislikes, of 335d, 235i,

335d +
* Torque on tap
* MPG 29-30 long term average
* HK audio
* effortless highway cruising
335d -
* many emissions OBD2 issues - luckily can do some DYI.
* floaty sports suspension - fixed by installing BMW Performance susp.
* base sports brakes...pads not up to task of cars potential (ie speed)

235i +
* Nice, wide, smooth torque band.
* nimble package and size
* Good overall compromise of suspension for daily/weekend
235i -
* Adap susp range : not enough soft, and not enough sport..
* base audio sound quality, no phone integration w base system..

Hope this helps in your search and decision making to find a well rounded daily,