Thanks for the feedback! I got a square set on my staggered wheels, a slight stretch in the rear but nothing you can really notice! I'm looking forward to checking them out in the snow. Did a short trip with them and road noise wasn't really too bad and handled well (dry & warm outside).
That said, I'm not too happy with the BMW dealer as I also did an alignment, but they introduced a slight pull to the right and they will be hearing about it for sure. Was a $600 oil change, hahahaha
Free oil change but while it's there you let them do other stuff... I'll learn