[Jason]

BIMMERPOST NEWS

BMW M235i vs Mercedes CLA 250 Sport Visual Comparo

76
COMMENTS

Tweet

Now that we've spied an uncovered 2 Series, let's take a look at how it stacks up visually against what will be one of main competitors - the Mercedes CLA sedan (with Sport package). One may be a coupe and the other a sedan with coupe-like styling, but this is the closest match we have, until the rumored 2 Series Gran Coupe is revealed.

Once the 2 Series official specs and photos are released, we'll put together another comparo comparing official photos, as well as physical specs.

Follow our 2 Series coverage at: http://www.bimmerpost.com/2-series/

Share this story

OTHER STORIES YOU MIGHT LIKE

Sibling Rivalry: BMW M235i Coupe vs M135i Hatchback

Breaking: BMW M235i Uncovered!

BMW M235i Seen in Valencia Orange. Gives Preview of Front End Styling [+ Render]

[Red Bread]

No contest there, but then I just can't warm to the fwd look of any car.

[bimmerjph]

I prefer everything about the 2er, except for the character lines. I am a sucker for upward moving swage lines.

[Alpine*]

M235 > Cla > A45 >> M135

[touringfanatic]

CLA is going down, you can't argue with rear wheel drive...

[Year's_End]

Originally Posted by bimmerjph

I prefer everything about the 2er, except for the character lines. I am a sucker for upward moving swage lines.

Not to mention the CLA's panel gaps are executed extremely well, extending that line into and past the rear quarter panel.

I honestly call this a draw. The 2er looks more naturally athletic given its stance and proportions, while the CLA looks a little more upscale, with more intricate detailing (grille accents, skirt inserts, headlights intricacies, etc.) and flowing sheetmetal (particularly where the hood meets the A-pillar; it's rather odd looking in the 2's case).

As an enthusiast I'd pick the M235i without batting an eyelid, but I imagine that the general public would perceive the CLA as the more upscale car.

[bizzyqu]

CLA needs more kink

[AlexK]

M235i looks more attractive to me, at least from exterior design point of view. CLA's front end looks needlessly "overweight", and these awful headlamps and tail lights look like they were designed by an Asian designer (which might not matter for some people, but it doesn't look "Mercedes" enough for me)... Same goes for most recent Mercedes refreshes/redesigns. No wonder they are trying to make their emblem more visible (so less people mistake it for something else) ;-)

[宝马.e90]

Sporty/aggressive look, I think has to go to the CLA...but then the rear tails completely ruin it for me but it's not something that would prevent me from buying one. Got to wait until the rear is completely revealed but right now, the CLA seems to be the winner.

I could see the Merc getting most of the looks and being somewhat more upscale than the 2-Series but that's something that the public has to realize, no matter what, the BMW is always going to have that sporty/vanilla look vs. the Merc where the details are much more defined to give it that luxury/premium look.

[Ian///M]

That Merc is terrible... front and rear are too proportional to each other

[Diver]

The rear end styling of the M235i appears to be the main improvement over the outgoing 1 series coupe. It isn't so abrupt. If it drives just like the M135i everyone will love it.

[64-bit]

I'm a BMW hardcore fan but... Mercedes did a better job on designing the exterior, it looks better than the 2 series

But, there is always a but...

Mercedes will never match the RWD experience that you get from bmw + BMW dash + sport seats

[Norsk]

New 2 Series coupe is looking

That Mercedes

Current BMS 3 Series front

[Mako]

Originally Posted by 64-bit

I'm a BMW hardcore fan but... Mercedes did a better job on designing the exterior, it looks better than the 2 series

But, there is always a but...

Mercedes will never match the RWD experience that you get from bmw + BMW dash + sport seats

Sport seats aren't available on the CLA? and price wise won't a CLA AMG compare more with the M235i? if it does, the seats in that thing are amazing! I do agree on the dash though, the CLA looks horrible, with that tiny little screen, looks like its an aftermarket add on. the 2 series looks the same as the 3 series for the dash and that is a good thing, I love the 3 series dash and nav screen (didn't think I would at first, but I do now after owning one for 7 months).

Next car will hopefully be a M2 Gran Coupe but only if its out by Fall 2015.

[Math]

Originally Posted by 64-bit

I'm a BMW hardcore fan but... Mercedes did a better job on designing the exterior, it looks better than the 2 series

But, there is always a but...

Mercedes will never match the RWD experience that you get from bmw + BMW dash + sport seats

Well said!!

[thetedderbear]

Based on looks alone, I've gotta give this one to the Merc. Those headlights on the BMW look terribly out of proportion.

[GJR]

Design-wise, Mercedes wins easily.

[Powaup]

CLA AWD could compete with the M235i xdrive. I like the benz because of the front and the fact that we know it comes with a DCT standard as far as the M235i there's a lot of unanswered questions concerning the transmissions other then that the m235i has won me over wish we had a picture of it in alpine white

[M3 Montreal]

As someone else mentioned...

The M235 should be compared to the CLA Amg and I'm sure that will have more aggressive styling.

Looking at the comparisons I would have to say the Merc looks a bit better.

Another NEW competitor I would like to see side by side is the new up and coming Audi S3 which is no longer a mini wagon.

From the pics I've seen of the S3 I'd pick that over these 2.

http://youtu.be/GF6PDp1INEQ

S-Tronic is Audis DCT and if it has an optional rear sport differential it will drive amazingly well through the corners.

And here's the CLA AMG

http://www.thecrosbypress.com/2013/03/19/the-2014-mercedes-benz-cla-45-amg/

Video: http://youtu.be/cf-9nSc1M70

[Merked M3]

I know everyone here is a BMW fan, but honestly the CLA looks way nicer!!!

I wouldn't want to buy it in FWD but in the looks department Benz def wins that one.

[soupermann]

Are the front bumper air vents on the CLA 250 functional (i.e., are there air ducts behind them that cool off the brakes/rotors)? I doubt it. They seem to be solid plastic slats like the g37s coupe that's part of a "sporty aggressive" design trend and unlike what we have on the 135.

[WULFFZA]

Interesting what people find appealing an what not.

I cannot compare these two as they are not in the same class.

I think the new CLS is stunning, but squash that design into a smaller fwd platform and it looks like a squished cartoon noddy car. I don't think it's (the CLA) svelte at all. As others have said, the front end is overtly heavy in design, a big gaping maw on a small car. The wheels look like they have been stuck onto rather than into the wheel arches, presumably to allow enough room for two (short) adults in the back. The tail is too short to appreciate the swooping curves.

I don't think the 2 series is perfect, but the smoothed out and swept back grill and elongated headlights are better than the old or new 1series and we're breathing a sigh of relief there. I wonder if this is a sign of what the sooner than expected F20 LCI model will look like upfront.

For me the rear 3 quarter pose on the old 1 coupe was its best angle, not that that stubby tale would work here, from what we can see here I think the taillights are bit too smoothed out. A small BMW should be chunky and stroppy looking. I'm interested nonetheless!