Is it odd that a fan of the 6-Speed manual is impressed with the 8-Speed Automatic? |
Post Reply |
|
Thread Tools | Search this Thread |
09-21-2014, 01:16 PM | #23 |
Brigadier General
504
Rep 3,446
Posts |
Whenever the topic of 6MT vs automatic of any kind comes up it seems like the world is made up of at least 50% MT drivers. Automotive journalists are fond of making statements like it is a waste to get some car or other with an automatic transmission.
The reality at BMW is the take rate for 6MT is in the low single digits and automotive journalists drive beat up Accords and Camrys when they are not working. I bet they are not driving those manual transmission test cars from the suburbs to a downtown office in rush hour traffic every weekday.
__________________
See my photography at http://ronscubadiver.wordpress.com
|
Appreciate
0
|
09-21-2014, 01:23 PM | #24 |
First Lieutenant
9
Rep 347
Posts |
Does "old and grouchy" qualify as a handicap?
__________________
F22 * (N55 + 6MT) ÷ PSS = FUN
|
Appreciate
0
|
09-21-2014, 02:01 PM | #26 |
Lieutenant
287
Rep 439
Posts |
Always so funny for me to read these people saying the 8-speed is so amazing and fun . . . I settled for one (with paddles) for my wife's car because I had to, and sure, it's pretty good relative to other slushboxes. But that's like being the world's tallest midget. It doesn't deliver anywhere near the driving experience, for me, that a manual does. As in, not even close.
The driving experience is so so so different with auto vs manual, in my mind there is no point in even comparing them. If you like auto, that's awesome, congrats--no reason to compare it to a manual. Some people like to eat good food at restaurants, and others prefer to make the good food themselves--good food is being eaten either way. But you can't really compare cooking your own food and someone cooking it for you.
__________________
2014 981 Cayman S 6MT, X73 Suspension, SES 2021 X5 45e MSport, Manhattan Green, Coffee Merino, Review & Photos Previous: '18 340 GT, '15 M235i 6MT, '15 i3 REx, '15 x1 xDrive28i |
Appreciate
0
|
09-21-2014, 02:08 PM | #27 |
Captain
95
Rep 809
Posts
Drives: 2014 228i Msport
Join Date: Jan 2012
Location: Charlotte, NC
|
Glad to see this has turned into another my trans is better than your trans thread. Can never have enough of those.
__________________
A peasant and proud of it
Save The Manuals!!! |
Appreciate
0
|
09-21-2014, 04:01 PM | #28 | |
Colonel
398
Rep 2,181
Posts
Drives: .
Join Date: Nov 2011
Location: -
iTrader: (0)
Garage List 2018 Audi RSQ3 (8U) [0.00]
2022 BMW X3 xDrive3 ... [10.00] 2015 BMW M235i (F22) [10.00] 2017 Mini Cooper S ... [0.00] |
Quote:
|
|
Appreciate
0
|
09-21-2014, 04:19 PM | #29 |
Brigadier General
504
Rep 3,446
Posts |
__________________
See my photography at http://ronscubadiver.wordpress.com
|
Appreciate
0
|
09-21-2014, 05:09 PM | #30 |
Brigadier General
898
Rep 3,071
Posts |
The issue is different compared to say 20 or even 10 years ago. Traditionally manual cars were faster. Now with dual clutch trannys and the amazing ZF 8 speed, the automatics have overtaken the manual as the performance drivers preferred method of driving. faster, better control (two hands on wheel at all times), better launches etc. Sure rowing is fun (I own to manuals), but the issue has shifted.
__________________
Previous BMW: 16 M4, 13 M6; 14 M235i, 12 BMW M3; 11 BMW M3; 08 BMW M3; 08 BMW Z4M; 04 X3; 02 M3 Convertible; 02 M3; 00 M Roadster; 94 325 convertible; 92 325i Convertible; and 85 635csi
My Car Photo Blog: http://carfisheye.blogspot.com/ |
Appreciate
0
|
09-21-2014, 05:18 PM | #31 | |
Major General
4654
Rep 6,029
Posts |
Quote:
|
|
Appreciate
0
|
09-21-2014, 05:22 PM | #32 |
Colonel
398
Rep 2,181
Posts
Drives: .
Join Date: Nov 2011
Location: -
iTrader: (0)
Garage List 2018 Audi RSQ3 (8U) [0.00]
2022 BMW X3 xDrive3 ... [10.00] 2015 BMW M235i (F22) [10.00] 2017 Mini Cooper S ... [0.00] |
Last edited by Vervain; 09-21-2014 at 06:39 PM.. |
Appreciate
0
|
09-21-2014, 05:49 PM | #33 | |
Brigadier General
504
Rep 3,446
Posts |
Quote:
In fact, it is probably fuel consumption more than anything else that has fueled the development of 7, 8 and 9 speed automatics. Computer technology has given us faster shifts and launch control at a lower cost than analog hydraulic controls.
__________________
See my photography at http://ronscubadiver.wordpress.com
|
|
Appreciate
0
|
09-21-2014, 06:12 PM | #34 |
Major General
4654
Rep 6,029
Posts |
23/36 automatic v 22/34 stick (per BMW site for 228i) is not, for me, a deciding factor. Those differences get lost in driving style. Show me a 5mpg difference and I start to pay more attention.
Last edited by Sportstick; 09-21-2014 at 06:19 PM.. |
Appreciate
0
|
09-21-2014, 09:37 PM | #35 |
Captain
413
Rep 678
Posts |
The auto is a very nice, crisp, quick and precise but if you really prefer the manual experience then get the manual and don't look back.
You have a flex work schedule and you only drive 8k miles a year has manual transmission written all over it IMO. I got my laundry list of reasons why a auto makes sense for me and why I would get an auto again but if I did not have that laundry list.....
__________________
2022 M4 Comp X 2021 M440ix - Sold 2015 M235 - Sold |
Appreciate
0
|
09-22-2014, 05:53 AM | #36 |
Brigadier General
898
Rep 3,071
Posts |
I will also add that the addition of paddle shifting is also a factor, as it allows a driver to feel more involved in driving. Unless you have driven a good dct you do not have grounds to compare, and the 8 speed is pretty close. Also, on most modern cars the automatic is a better match for the cars power. With a take up rate south of 10%, why waste money on fine tuning, and in Germany where they do not like manuals, I am sure it is given even more short shrift as they know that most manuals go to Americans (which I am sure drives them crazy given their idea that we are all fat with 128 oz. big gulp cups in one hand a fast food in the other, how do we even shift??).
__________________
Previous BMW: 16 M4, 13 M6; 14 M235i, 12 BMW M3; 11 BMW M3; 08 BMW M3; 08 BMW Z4M; 04 X3; 02 M3 Convertible; 02 M3; 00 M Roadster; 94 325 convertible; 92 325i Convertible; and 85 635csi
My Car Photo Blog: http://carfisheye.blogspot.com/ |
Appreciate
0
|
09-22-2014, 07:09 AM | #37 |
Second Lieutenant
51
Rep 269
Posts |
|
Appreciate
0
|
09-22-2014, 07:25 AM | #38 |
Brigadier General
898
Rep 3,071
Posts |
From BMW. While it is true that at the low end the cars are manuals, at the high end the buyers want auto boxes. For example, the M5 only had smg until the US buyers demanded a manual.
"Frolich also confirmed that for the foreseeable future, the manual transmission is safe at BMW, both in M Division cars and regular non-performance models. “Of course, with a manual you are slower, but it is more emotional; it now says ‘I am a serious driver, I am a connoisseur’. So, we will continue [to offer a manual] even if only ten per cent of customers want it. That is why we offer a manual M5 sedan in North America. It is stupid – the development costs are huge – but we will keep doing it as long as the customer wants it.” another quote from BMW: BMW says manual transmissions are on the way out, insisting that fuel efficiency and performance benefits are no longer an advantage for the do-it-yourself system. Speaking with CarAdvice at the launch of the 2014 BMW X5 in Vancouver last week, the company’s product line director, Peter Wolf, hinted that BMW doesn’t view manual transmissions as a big part of its future. “It is no longer a question of sportiness as the automatic and dual-clutch gearboxes are quicker now [than manual transmissions],” Wolf said. “They are also more efficient, which is a big advantage too. I don’t think we will see a manual gearbox much more in the future.” "In Europe, Mercedes-Benz, BMW and Audi are the top three manufacturers with the highest uptake of automatic transmission vehicles respectively, with Germany leading Europe in the move towards self-shifting vehicles." "The BMW M5 is only available with a manual transmission in North America where, surprisingly, market demand has led BMW to put a six-speed gearbox in its 5 Series performance flagship as a no-cost option to the seven-speed dual-clutch transmission."
__________________
Previous BMW: 16 M4, 13 M6; 14 M235i, 12 BMW M3; 11 BMW M3; 08 BMW M3; 08 BMW Z4M; 04 X3; 02 M3 Convertible; 02 M3; 00 M Roadster; 94 325 convertible; 92 325i Convertible; and 85 635csi
My Car Photo Blog: http://carfisheye.blogspot.com/ |
Appreciate
0
|
09-22-2014, 08:59 AM | #39 |
Brigadier General
504
Rep 3,446
Posts |
I agree that at the consumer level it is not a deciding factor but for the manufacturer who is working hard to exceed regulatory limits it is. These incremental improvements actually have a cash value as they can be sold to another manufacturer that is not meeting their requirements. So money goes to develop new automatics and BMW does not charge extra for the auto in the US.
__________________
See my photography at http://ronscubadiver.wordpress.com
|
Appreciate
0
|
09-22-2014, 09:16 AM | #40 | |
Major General
4654
Rep 6,029
Posts |
Quote:
The pricing for the automatic is in the feature value build up for the base car. Over history (although I don't know ZF recent internal financials), the variable piece cost of a manual EXCEEDED that of an automatic, just another example of where cost and price have little to no relationship. Selling automatics over base manuals has been one of the industry's great economics boons for decades. Cost drops and revenue increases. By pricing the car with an automatic, BMW is covering the likely higher variable piece cost of the manual for those who take the "no credit" option". I don't doubt that sticks are on the way out. Good reason to buy one now and take great care of it. Those of us with this preference are in the minority. According to a database I can access, future industry intention for manual is 6%, and for BMW, 8%, so the inevitable will become apparent. |
|
Appreciate
0
|
09-22-2014, 10:32 AM | #41 |
Private First Class
25
Rep 136
Posts |
AT vs MT is subjective in the new world of 8 speed ZF, DCT etc..
Like playing coin operated real pin ball vs playing pin ball on the computer. The lights and sound are as real as it gets and you can even bump on the sides on the computer. AT fun factor may wear off and you will start hankering for MT. Never other way round unless you get some pain/injury in your left leg or right hand...in the USA |
Appreciate
0
|
09-22-2014, 01:11 PM | #42 |
Captain
356
Rep 928
Posts
Drives: 2007 328i Coupe, ZSP, Premium
Join Date: Feb 2013
Location: Knoxville
|
The novelty of the auto will wear off quickly and you will miss the MT if you are a true manual die hard.
|
Appreciate
0
|
09-22-2014, 02:43 PM | #43 |
Chief Warrant Officer
1025
Rep 1,638
Posts |
I too am a diehard manual fan, but the M235 I test drove with the 8AT was incredibly impressive!. Best AT I've ever driven, and undeniably faster on the shift than my 25 years of manual rowing experience can pull off.
That said, I envision a day when I will no longer be able to get the cars I want in MT, so I am going to keep getting them while I still can. I drive in stop-and-go commute every day in the Boston area and I still don't mind MT. To me that's just driving. I feel more engaged. However, I am also a helicopter pilot, so having both hands and both feet on the controls is second nature to me and not fatiguing in the least. So, 6MT for me, but that 8AT is so good I would never give anyone a hard time for choosing it if it felt right to them. |
Appreciate
0
|
09-22-2014, 04:15 PM | #44 | |
Chief Warrant Officer
1025
Rep 1,638
Posts |
Quote:
Also, in all of my trips to Europe, you have to pay an upcharge to get an automatic rental, otherwise you get a manual (opposite of the 'States where you can't even get manual rentals). Bottom line: Europe is still VASTLY more manual-centric than the small % of manual drivers in the US. Including in Germany, where M5s are as rare as they are here, and everyone can at least drive a manual, whether they choose to or not (and far more do over there than here). I'm not arguing the auto vs. manual debate, just making sure we have our facts straight about who drives more manuals (Europeans). Don't believe me? go there for yourself. |
|
Appreciate
0
|
Post Reply |
Bookmarks |
|
|