|
Going through this very debate right now.
Past decisions...
2007.....335 vs 328 (I-6).... 335 won - no regrets
2013........x3 3.5 vs x3 2.8....3.5 with no regrets
2013........X1 3.5 vs X1 2.8.....3.5 won but I think that the 4 banger turbo might have been the better choice in this case partly because of the crappy 6 speed auto in the 3.5 and partly because this car feels heavy without the sports package.
Now, regarding the 2 series - I love how the 4 cylinder felt in a spirited test drive - it's the anti x3 / X1...refined, yet Light, nimble, enough power without overpowering its chassis. There is something magical less the exhaust/engine sounds the 235 provides.
Having driven only the inline 6 turbo for the last 9 years, I'm strongly/strangely considering a 228i With only the 8 speed auto + technology package + THP + LCA mod + LSD with the goal of keeping her as light as possible.
Perhaps I should clarify... The car will be for daily commute + auto-X + teaching a new teen to drive....no road trips.
By the time I make my decision it will be a 240 vs 230 debate.
|