Price seems high especially (maybe because of?) it being in the US. I was hunting for the M235i for the last 4 months or so, and in Canada they are going for around $36k to $39k CAD ($27.5K to 30k USD) for the fully loaded models, mostly x-drive and auto, for 2014s and 2015s, generally with under 25k miles.
e.g. this one is a fully loaded 2016.
https://vancouver.craigslist.ca/nvn/...627834605.html. This one only has 14k miles!
I ended up picking a AW 2015 RWD w 1yr of factory warranty and service left, AT, No options except Sunroof, Heated steering and Terra leather (really wanted comfort access but oh well), with 14k Miles for about $25k USD. No accidents, brand new tires all around (nail in tire at the dealer when I went to pick up the car - that's another story).
Moral of the long story - the deals are out there, but you have to search and wait for it. Might also be worth looking at the Canadian cars - I'm surprised that in this case (usually very rarely seen), it seems CAD M235is were generally cheaper than US ones!