View Single Post
      08-12-2016, 01:01 PM   #10
griz31
Second Lieutenant
griz31's Avatar
United_States
174
Rep
254
Posts

Drives: 2020 BMW 330xi
Join Date: May 2016
Location: Northern Virginia

iTrader: (0)

Quote:
Originally Posted by kdog26372 View Post
I look forward to my daily commute in my m235i. It's a nice balance of power, handling and comfort. Make no mistake this is not a full on track car like an M3 or M2 so you will get some minor roll around corners and the suspension/tires won't feel like on rails like those. M2 is probably the perfect car for you. Otherwise, toss on a cheap $300 tune and it'll at least feel like a new and more exciting car for a few months until you get used to the extra power. Lots of suspension mods can be done to help with handling and intercooler will help with the hot weather issue. But once you've spent money on tune/intercooler/suspension mods you'd probably have been better off just placing order for the M2 and calling it a day. Just my $.02. Cayman S would be on at the short list of fun loving drivers car too, depending on your budget as that's gonna be M4 $.

For the similar price range of M235i you've got the Audi S3 and TTS, base Cayman, MB CLA45 and BMW M2 in terms of the big 4 German competition. Realistically after pricing out options and real world pricing after negotiations the S3 is the only one that will price out the same, it's got a better interior, but the drive isn't as good as the m235i and the DCT has terrible lag during stop/go. The 0-60 numbers are essentially bogus as it's all DCT launch control magic and in the real world it ain't all that fast and doesn't have Audi's normally excellent AWD system.

Test drive an M2 if you can find one or maybe a local member to you will offer to let you drive along. Go drive the others listed if you are ok spending a bit more $ and see what gets your blood pumping.
Great feedback, thank you! It really just comes down to my subjective preferences in terms of how I feel about the car. I would give up some of the comfort for more sport feeling. While I know a lot of people do mods on a lease and just return the car back to stock, just seems like a lot of effort and money for something that might break lease terms or void warranties. I did put MPSS on as this came with run-flats, but as that is a factory option its hard to consider that a true "mod". Maybe something I will reconsider later as options to really enjoy the car more.

Also, thanks for pointing out other cars in the segment. I have looked at many of the ones you mentioned, but haven't test driven them specifically. I test drove a couple s4's, 435i, and even went the whole other way and got in a Mustang GT. The m235i was hands down the best out of all of them. What I wish I had tried/looked at as well (or waited for) -- M2, better condition E9x M, F8x M platform, Cayman platform, BMW 1 series platform.

Unfortunately I'm not really in a position to move on to anything else just yet. Rolling in almost all my costs into my lease terms and doing MSD's doesn't make for a very desireable lease transfer, and the car is too new to consider selling without losing significant money. I am relatively young with a lot of years of driving ahead to make an emotionally irrational financial decision for a car, haha! And honestly, the m235i isn't some miserable car that I hate driving -- especially to the point of throwing money away on. I do really like it.
Appreciate 0